The best second-hand car to buy right now

For most buyers, the best second‑hand car is a late‑model Toyota Corolla (2019–2022) or Toyota Prius (2016–2022) for unmatched reliability, low running costs, and strong safety. If you prefer an SUV, the Mazda CX‑5 (2017–2021) and Toyota RAV4 (2019–2021) are standouts; for a premium feel with economy, look to a Lexus RX (2016–2020) or Lexus ES (2019–2021). On a budget EV, a Chevrolet Bolt or Bolt EUV (2020–2023) with a confirmed battery replacement is hard to beat. That said, the “best” used car depends on how you drive, what you can maintain, and local market pricing.

What “best” means in the used car market

Choosing a used car is a balance of reliability, total cost of ownership, safety, and how well the car fits your life. Market conditions and regional differences matter: availability, climate (rust), and local service expertise can tilt the decision. The models below are drawn from longstanding reliability leaders and widely reported ownership data up to late 2024.

Here are the key factors that typically define a great second‑hand buy and why they matter.

• Reliability track record: Fewer major repairs and known issues over high mileage.
• Total cost of ownership: Fuel or electricity costs, insurance, parts prices, and depreciation.
• Safety: Crash-test performance and availability of modern driver-assistance features.
• Serviceability: Easy access to parts and experienced independent mechanics.
• Value retention: Cars that hold value well but still offer smart purchase prices used.

Balancing these factors narrows the field to models with consistent real‑world durability, reasonable running costs, and strong safety, which is why Toyota, Lexus, Mazda, and select Honda and Chevrolet EVs often surface as top choices.

Top second‑hand picks by category

Compact and midsize sedans/hatchbacks

These models are widely available, cheap to run, and tend to score well for reliability and safety. The years below aim to capture sweet spots after early‑generation teething issues and before tech becomes dated.

• Toyota Corolla (2019–2022): Efficient, safe, simple to maintain; hybrid trims are excellent for city drivers.
• Toyota Prius (2016–2022): Exceptional fuel economy; batteries and hybrid systems have strong longevity records.
• Toyota Camry (2018–2021): Comfortable, reliable; 4‑cyl models balance power and economy well.
• Mazda3 (2019–2021): Engaging to drive, upscale interior; look for rust protection in snowy regions.
• Honda Civic (2020–2021): Refined, efficient; verify A/C condenser and any outstanding service bulletins on earlier 10th‑gen cars.

These choices minimize ownership surprises while providing modern safety tech and infotainment. If you prioritize effortless economy above all, the Prius and Corolla Hybrid lead the pack.

Compact and midsize SUVs

SUVs dominate used demand; the models below blend reliability, efficiency, and family‑friendly practicality. Pay attention to tire condition and AWD service history if equipped.

• Mazda CX‑5 (2017–2021): Class‑leading drive feel and value; 2.5‑liter engine is a reliable pick.
• Toyota RAV4 (2019–2021): Strong reliability and resale; the Hybrid adds excellent economy.
• Subaru Outback (2017–2019) or Forester (2017–2018): Great in bad weather; aim for 2016+ to avoid earlier oil‑consumption issues.
• Honda CR‑V (2020–2021): Roomy and efficient; confirm that the 1.5T oil‑dilution concerns seen on earlier years were addressed.

For most families, the CX‑5 drives best, while RAV4 Hybrid maximizes savings. Subarus shine in snowbelt regions with proper maintenance.

Luxury sedans and SUVs

Lexus models are standouts for durability and lower surprise costs versus German rivals. These years align with strong reliability runs and modern driver assistance.

• Lexus RX (2016–2020): Quiet, comfortable, and reliable; hybrid trims add long‑term efficiency.
• Lexus ES (2019–2021): Premium ride with Toyota‑like running costs; hybrid trim is frugal.
• Lexus NX (2018–2021): Compact luxury SUV with solid reliability; check infotainment comfort before buying.

If you want a premium badge without premium repair bills, these Lexus models are perennial used‑market sweet spots.

Affordable used EVs

EV values have softened, creating bargains—especially where charging is easy. Battery health and recall history are crucial checks.

• Chevrolet Bolt EV/EUV (2020–2023): Excellent value and range; verify the battery recall was completed with a replacement pack and that latest software is installed.
• Tesla Model 3 (2019–2021): Strong charging network and performance; inspect build quality and have the high‑voltage system evaluated if out of warranty.
• Nissan Leaf (2018–2019, 40 kWh): Affordable city car; simpler cooling system means watch for battery degradation in hot climates.

For most budgets, a post‑recall Bolt is the low‑stress EV buy; a used Model 3 suits road‑trippers who value Supercharger access and can vet condition carefully.

Trucks and 3‑row family haulers

Trucks hold value and can be costly to run; focus on models with proven drivetrains and service records. For 3‑row needs, target reliability and safety over gadgets.

• Toyota Tacoma (2016–2021): Durable and retains value; ride quality is truck‑like, but reliability is excellent.
• Ford F‑150 (2015–2020, 2.7L EcoBoost or 5.0L V8 with records): Broad parts availability; confirm maintenance and any timing/cam‑phaser updates.
• Toyota Highlander (2017–2020, including Hybrid): Family‑friendly, efficient, and dependable.

Expect higher purchase prices for clean trucks; thorough inspections and documented maintenance make all the difference here.

Model‑year caveats and issues to watch

Even good nameplates have years or components to approach with caution. The items below are widely reported patterns; individual cars with proper fixes and records can still be solid buys.

• Honda 1.5‑liter turbo (2017–2019 CR‑V; 2018–2020 Accord): Reports of fuel dilution in cold climates—seek later builds, verified software fixes, and oil‑change history.
• Hyundai/Kia Theta II engines (approx. 2011–2019 in various models): Some suffered bearing failures; confirm recall/compliance and extended warranty status.
• Subaru FB engines (earlier 2011–2015): Oil consumption complaints—prefer 2016+ or cars with documented engine updates.
• Ford dual‑clutch (Powershift) automatics (Focus/Fiesta ~2011–2016): Known transmission issues—generally avoid unless fully remedied with warranty documentation.
• Nissan CVT concerns (various models mid‑2010s): Mixed reliability—verify long warranty coverage, fluid changes, and smooth operation on a long test drive.
• Chevrolet Bolt EV (2017–2019 original packs): Ensure battery recall was performed with a replacement pack, not just a software limiter.

Use these notes as screening tools, not absolute bans. A clean history, updated parts, and strong maintenance records can outweigh a model‑year’s reputation.

What to check before you buy

Inspections and documentation prevent most used‑car regrets. Budget time and a small fee for a professional evaluation—it’s cheaper than one major repair.

• Independent pre‑purchase inspection: Lift check for leaks, suspension wear, rust, and brake/tires.
• Service history: Regular oil changes and timely fluid service matter more than odometer alone.
• Recalls and TSBs: Confirm completion; many fixes are free at franchised dealers.
• Accident and flood checks: Use history reports and look for corrosion, musty smells, mismatched panels.
• Test drive route: Include highway, stop‑and‑go, and rough pavement; verify transmission shift quality and alignment.
• EV‑specific: Request battery health data, DC fast‑charge history, and charging port condition; test on a Level 2 charger.
• Ownership costs: Get insurance quotes and price common wear items (tires, brakes, 12V battery, hybrid cooling service).

A systematic check reduces uncertainty and strengthens your negotiation power, often saving more than the inspection cost.

Pricing and market timing

Used prices surged in 2021–2022, eased through 2023–2024, and remain variable by segment. Hybrids and reliable SUVs still command premiums; many EVs have softened, improving value. Shop broadly, compare out‑of‑area listings, and be patient for the right spec. If financing, factor higher interest rates into total cost—sometimes a slightly older, cheaper car saves more overall.

Insurance and running costs

Reliable doesn’t always mean cheap to insure or maintain. Get quotes before committing, especially on EVs and luxury trims with pricey bodywork. Hybrids like the Prius/Corolla Hybrid often deliver the lowest lifetime costs. Keep a reserve fund for wear items, and avoid skipping preventive maintenance—small services prevent big bills.

Bottom line

If you want the safest bet across budgets, prioritize a well‑maintained Toyota Corolla (2019–2022) or Prius (2016–2022). For an SUV, target a Mazda CX‑5 (2017–2021) or Toyota RAV4 (2019–2021); for affordable luxury, Lexus RX (2016–2020) or ES (2019–2021); for a value EV, a post‑recall Chevrolet Bolt (2020–2023). Always verify recalls, inspect professionally, and buy the best-documented example you can find.

What is the best second hand car to purchase?

What are the most reliable used cars to buy?

• Honda Civic.
• Honda Accord.
• Toyota Corolla.
• Toyota Camry.
• Mazda 6.
• Lexus ES.
• Acura TSX.
• Toyota RAV4.

What is the most reliable used car to buy?

The most reliable car brands to purchase used in 2025 are Kia, Chevy, Toyota, Hyundai, and Honda. That’s why our three Used Car Superstores locations focus their inventory on these five automakers!

What is the best brand for a second-hand car?

We will explore what makes these brands stand out and why they are worth your investment.

• Toyota. For this reason, Toyota has long been considered one of the best-used car brands.
• Honda. Honda is another brand that is synonymous with durability and low maintenance costs.
• Subaru.
• Ford.
• Nissan.
• Chevrolet.
• BMW.
• Audi.

What is the most reliable second-hand car?

What are the most reliable used cars with high mileage?

• Kia Sportage.
• Lexus RX.
• VW Passat.
• Honda Civic.
• Mercedes-Benz W123.
• Ford Fiesta.
• Mazda MX-5.
• Toyota Prius. Although no longer produced or sold, the Prius (2016-22) has an impressive reliability rating of 97% and an overall used car score of 76% (The Car Expert).