The best reliable second‑hand car to buy

For most buyers seeking maximum reliability with low running costs, a late‑model Toyota Corolla (2018–2022) is the safest all‑around bet; if you want a dependable SUV with a premium feel, a Lexus RX (2016–2020) is a standout. Both have excellent long‑term durability records, strong safety performance and manageable ownership costs, according to multiple reliability surveys through 2024.

Why there isn’t one single “best” for everyone

“Best” depends on what you need: size, body style, budget, fuel economy, and local market availability. Reliability leaders tend to be Toyotas, Lexuses, Mazdas and Hondas across many segments, but the right choice for a commuter differs from that for a family of five or someone who tows. Below, we highlight top picks that consistently score well in independent reliability and dependability studies, then explain what years to target and what to check before you buy.

Best overall picks most shoppers can trust

The following two models have an exceptional reliability track record, wide parts availability, and good resale support, making them safe choices in many markets.

• Toyota Corolla (2018–2022): Compact sedan/hatch with proven engines, excellent fuel economy (high 30s mpg; hybrid trims exceed 50 mpg), low maintenance costs, and top-tier reliability across surveys through 2024.
• Lexus RX (2016–2020): Mid-size luxury SUV with smooth V6 or hybrid powertrains, strong comfort and durability; among the most dependable premium SUVs over the past decade.

These models balance everyday practicality with long-term durability, making them easy recommendations when you want a low-risk purchase.

Top reliable used cars by category

If your needs are more specific, the models below are consistently reliable choices within their segments, based on aggregated results from major reliability studies (e.g., Consumer Reports, J.D. Power VDS, What Car? UK) through 2024, plus known field history. Target the listed generations/years for the best mix of reliability and value.

• Budget city car: Toyota Yaris (2015–2020) or Honda Fit/Jazz (2015–2020) — simple, efficient, easy to maintain.
• Compact car: Toyota Corolla (2018–2022) or Mazda3 (2019–2021) — Corolla for lowest running costs, Mazda3 for more engaging drive.
• Midsize car: Toyota Camry (2018–2021) or Lexus ES (2013–2018; 2019–2021) — both excellent long-term bets; ES adds luxury with Toyota-like durability.
• Hybrid: Toyota Prius (2016–2022) — benchmark reliability and fuel economy; battery packs routinely last well over 150,000 miles with proper care.
• Small SUV: Toyota RAV4 (2016–2018; 2019–2021) or Mazda CX‑5 (2017–2021) — RAV4 for bulletproof simplicity; CX‑5 for better driving dynamics.
• Family SUV: Toyota Highlander (2014–2019) — robust V6 and roomy interior; strong dependability history.
• Luxury SUV: Lexus RX (2016–2020) or Lexus GX 460 (2014–2020) — RX is the refined pick; GX is ultra-durable but thirsty.
• Wagon/Adventure: Subaru Outback (2015–2019) — capable and safe; check for diligent maintenance; 2019+ introduced more driver tech.
• Sports/roadster: Mazda MX‑5 Miata (2016–2021) — simple, light, and reliably fun; low running costs.
• Minivan: Toyota Sienna (2015–2020) — proven V6 drivetrain; fewer transmission concerns than many rivals.

While availability and pricing vary by region, these models commonly combine strong dependability with reasonable parts and service costs, making them solid used buys.

Why these cars stand out

Toyota and Lexus top most reliability rankings year after year, with Mazda and Honda close behind. These brands favor proven powertrains, conservative calibrations, and strong parts support. Hybrids from Toyota (Prius, Corolla Hybrid, RAV4 Hybrid) have particularly robust electric components and battery management, contributing to long service life when maintained. Mazda’s simpler naturally aspirated engines and Honda’s well-sorted platforms also contribute to fewer major repairs over time.

Years and trims to target or approach with caution

Even reliable nameplates have better and worse years. Use this quick guide to focus your search and avoid known headaches.

• Toyota Corolla: Target 2019–2022 (12th gen) for modern safety tech and efficiency; earlier 2017–2018 models are also strong.
• Toyota Camry: 2018–2021 (8th gen) is a sweet spot; verify recall completion for fuel pump campaigns on some 2018–2020 vehicles.
• Toyota RAV4: 2016–2018 (refreshed 4th gen) very solid; 2019–2021 (5th gen) generally reliable, though some early 2019–2020 owners reported minor transmission shift smoothness that was often addressed via updates.
• Honda Civic: 2016–2021 (10th gen) is a good pick; check for repaired A/C condenser issues on early years.
• Honda CR‑V: Prefer 2020+ 1.5T or 2015–2016 2.4L; 2017–2019 1.5T models in cold climates had oil dilution complaints—ensure updates were applied and oil analysis is clean.
• Mazda3 and CX‑5: 2019–2021 (3) and 2017–2021 (CX‑5) are strong; keep up with fluid service and watch for rust in heavy-salt regions on older cars.
• Toyota Prius: 2016–2022 (Gen 4) is exceptionally dependable; avoid neglected Gen 3 (2010–2015) cars with EGR-related issues unless thoroughly documented repairs are present.
• Lexus RX: 2016–2020 (Gen 4) is a safe bet; 2020+ gained improved infotainment; hybrids add efficiency without typical hybrid headaches.
• Hyundai/Kia (2011–2021, selected models): Be mindful of theft/vandalism risk on non-immobilizer cars in some markets; ensure anti-theft updates or immobilizer retrofits are in place, and verify engine recall history on models with Theta II engines.

Focusing on these years reduces the odds of inheriting known flaws and increases your chance of getting updated components and software from prior owner service campaigns.

Ownership costs and longevity

Reliability isn’t just fewer breakdowns—it’s predictable costs. Here’s what to expect from the standouts above.

• Routine maintenance: Toyotas, Lexuses, Mazdas and Hondas typically need only fluids, filters, brakes and tires on normal intervals; hybrids add little extra routine cost.
• Longevity: Many examples of Corolla, Camry, Prius, RX and Highlander routinely exceed 200,000 miles (320,000 km) with proper maintenance.
• Fuel economy: Corolla/Prus excel; Mazda3/CX‑5 are competitive; Lexus RX V6 is moderate, RX hybrid improves urban MPG.
• Insurance and depreciation: Mainstream Toyotas and Mazdas are economical to insure; Lexus holds value well, which may raise purchase price but helps resale.

Choosing a model with proven durability and straightforward maintenance helps you avoid unpredictable big-ticket repairs and supports strong resale value down the line.

How to choose the right one for you

Matching a reliable model to your use case ensures you actually benefit from its strengths. Consider the following factors as you narrow your shortlist.

• Daily drive profile: Short city hops favor hybrids (Prius, Corolla Hybrid); long highway miles suit Corolla/Camry/Mazda3 for comfort and economy.
• Space needs: RAV4/CX‑5 for small families; Highlander/RX for more room and comfort; Sienna for maximum passenger/cargo flexibility.
• Climate and terrain: AWD options (RAV4, CX‑5, Outback, RX) help in snow; corrosion protection matters in coastal/salt regions.
• Budget: Older Toyotas/Mazdas/Hondas may cost more up front but tend to repay with fewer repairs and stronger resale.

Balancing these priorities will guide you to the model that best fits your life while maintaining dependable performance over time.

Pre‑purchase checklist (avoid surprises)

Before you commit, a disciplined inspection process dramatically reduces risk, even on reliable models.

• Service history: Prefer cars with complete records and timely fluid changes; hybrids should show cooling system and brake service on schedule.
• Recalls and TSBs: Confirm all recalls are completed; ask dealers to check VIN for campaign history and software updates.
• Independent inspection: A pre‑purchase inspection (PPI) can catch leaks, suspension wear, brake and tire life, accident repairs and flood damage.
• Diagnostic scan: Request a full OBD scan for stored or pending codes; ensure all monitors are set (no recent code clearing).
• Road test: Check cold start behavior, transmission shift quality, alignment tracking, brake feel, A/C performance and infotainment function.
• Ownership costs: Price insurance, tires and typical maintenance for the exact trim; hybrid battery health can be assessed by specialists if mileage is high.

Completing these steps strengthens your negotiating position and helps you walk away from problem cars—no matter how reputable the badge.

The bottom line

If you want a single, broadly applicable answer: buy a well-kept Toyota Corolla (2018–2022). If you prefer a premium SUV with similar peace of mind, choose a Lexus RX (2016–2020). Beyond those, stick to the brands and years noted above, verify maintenance and recall history, and get a professional inspection. That formula will deliver a reliable second‑hand car in most markets.

Summary

Best reliable second‑hand picks: Toyota Corolla (2018–2022) for most buyers; Lexus RX (2016–2020) for a dependable SUV. Other strong options include Camry, Prius, RAV4, Mazda3, CX‑5, Highlander, Lexus ES, Subaru Outback, and Toyota Sienna in the years noted. Confirm service histories, complete recalls, and get a pre‑purchase inspection to lock in long-term reliability and value.

What is the most dependable used car to buy?

Toyota is often at the top of reliability rankings-and for good reason. This brand has built a legacy around longevity, practicality, and quality. Toyota Corolla: One of the world’s best-selling compact cars, the Corolla is known for its bulletproof reliability and outstanding fuel efficiency.

What is the most reliable car in the last 10 years?

Most Reliable Car Models of the Decade

• Toyota Corolla.
• Hyundai Elantra.
• Mazda 3.
• Lexus ES.
• Mazda 6.
• Toyota Highlander.
• Honda CR-V.
• Honda Accord. The Honda Accord is known for its outstanding reliability, making it a top choice for drivers who want a dependable vehicle.

Which is the most reliable second-hand car to buy?

Best Used Cars 2025: the shortlist

• Toyota Corolla (2019-present)
• Honda Jazz (2015-2020)
• Volkswagen Up (2012-2023)
• Ford Kuga (2019-present)
• BMW 5 Series (2017-2024)
• Skoda Octavia Estate (2013-2020)
• Volkswagen Golf GTI (2013-2020)
• Mazda MX-5 (2015-present)

Which car brand is best for second hand?

Toyota/Mazda typically top the charts overall for this. They also usually hold value better as a result, meaning they might be slightly more expensive options than comparable other manufacturers offerings in your range.